Home › Company Reviews › Old Republic vs Select

Old Republic Home Protection vs Select Home Warranty

✓No Inspection Required — Setup Online Now

Last updated: October 2026 · Consumer education page · Editorial disclaimer

Comparing Old Republic Home Protection vs Select Home Warranty? If you want a third option, Property Warranty offers a free personalized quote with no inspection required. This page provides a neutral, side-by-side comparison based on publicly available information. We do not accuse either company of wrongdoing — this page exists to help homeowners compare before purchasing.

Old Republic Home Protection vs Select Home Warranty at a glance

 Old Republic Home ProtectionSelect Home Warranty
Founded19742012
HeadquartersSan Ramon, CaliforniaMahwah, New Jersey
Plan tiersValue Plan, Enhanced Plan, Platinum PlanBronze Care, Gold Care, Platinum Care
Free quoteFree personalized quoteFree personalized quote

Plan names, fees, and coverage caps change frequently. Always confirm current details on each company's official site or in a written quote before buying.

Coverage themes — Old Republic

  • Online reviews reference Old Republic's long track record but some note that plan pricing has increased in recent years.
  • Some customers report disputes about coverage caps on HVAC replacement, particularly for older systems.
  • Public discussions mention regional contractor availability gaps in rural areas.

Coverage themes — Select

  • BBB and ConsumerAffairs pages reference complaints about reimbursement amounts being lower than repair costs.
  • Some customers report that approved third-party technicians took several days to schedule.
  • Public discussions mention difficulty navigating the cancellation process.

Which company is right for which homeowner?

Compare coverage: Old Republic and Select each offer different plan tiers. Compare the coverage details carefully to find the best fit for your home.

If you have an older home or older HVAC system: read the "pre-existing conditions" and "improper installation" sections in each contract first — these clauses are the most common source of public complaints across every home warranty company.

If you want a longer track record: Old Republic Home Protection has been in business longer (since 1974) and a longer history can make BBB ratings, public complaints, and review patterns easier to evaluate.

If you want a written quote without a phone call: you can get an independent home warranty quote in minutes — get a free personalized quote with no inspection required — useful as a third reference point alongside Old Republic and Select.

Frequently asked questions

Is Old Republic better than Select?

"Better" depends on what you need: best coverage for your systems, broadest contractor network, or shortest claim turnaround. Read each company's most recent reviews and a sample contract before deciding.

Do Old Republic and Select cover the same systems and appliances?

Both companies offer tiered plans that typically cover HVAC, plumbing, electrical, and major appliances. The differences are usually in coverage caps, exclusions, add-ons (pools, septic, roof leaks), and service-call fees.

Can I switch from one to the other mid-policy?

Yes. Most home warranty plans allow cancellation with a prorated refund after the first 30 days. New coverage from a different provider usually has a 30-day waiting period before claims are eligible.

Are there alternatives to both Old Republic and Select?

Yes — you can get a Property Warranty quote in minutes — free personalized quote, no inspection required — and use it as a third reference point.

Head-to-head comparisons

Best home warranty by city

New York, NY Los Angeles, CA Chicago, IL Houston, TX Phoenix, AZ Philadelphia, PA San Antonio, TX San Diego, CA Dallas, TX Austin, TX Jacksonville, FL Fort Worth, TX
Editorial disclaimer. This page is for consumer education only. We do not accuse any company of fraud or wrongdoing. Information may reference publicly available reviews, complaints, ratings, and consumer-reported experiences. Customers should verify details directly with the company before making decisions.
🛡

Get a Free Home Warranty Quote

Get your free personalized quote today. No inspection required.

Get Free Quote