America's First Choice Home Club Phone Number Lookup

Looking up a AFC phone number?

If you've received a call, text, or letter that mentions America's First Choice Home Club, this page explains what people commonly report about AFC-related contacts and how to verify any home warranty offer before you respond. We do not list specific phone numbers because they change frequently and because publishing the wrong number can mislead consumers; instead we explain how to verify a number is genuinely from the company.

America's First Choice Home Club is headquartered in Edison, New Jersey and has been in business since 2009 — that 17-year track record means there is a long public record of customer feedback for AFC on sites like the BBB, Trustpilot, ConsumerAffairs, and Google Reviews. Always verify the official customer-service number on the company's current contract or its direct .com domain — not on a cold-call caller ID or a mailer envelope.

If you already have an account with America's First Choice Home Club, your plan tier (Silver, Gold, Platinum, Diamond) and your service-fee schedule ($75–$125 service fee) should be printed on your most recent welcome packet or annual statement — a real account-holder call can confirm those details before asking you for anything.

What AFC customers commonly report online

Across publicly posted reviews, the recurring themes mentioned about America's First Choice Home Club include:

• Online reviews reference long hold times when filing a claim during winter and summer surge months.
• Some customers report disputes over what counts as a covered "system" versus an excluded component.
• Public discussions mention auto-renewal billing concerns.

These reflect what some customers report and are not a verified judgment about America's First Choice Home Club. Many other customers report positive experiences with the same company.

How to verify a AFC call or letter is genuine

1. Look up the customer service number on your existing contract or welcome packet, not the number on the caller ID.
2. If you do not have an existing policy, do not call back the number on a mailer — type the company's official domain name into your browser and use the contact page there.
3. Never share Social Security numbers, full bank account numbers, or your warranty deed in response to a cold call or unsolicited letter.
4. Ask the caller to confirm your account number, plan tier, and renewal date before you give them any information. Real account-holder calls already have this information.
5. Add your number to the National Do Not Call Registry at donotcall.gov and report unwanted calls to the FTC at reportfraud.ftc.gov.

What customers commonly report about AFC phone contacts

Online reviews of any large home warranty company sometimes reference high call volume during peak season, multiple call-backs to resolve a single claim, and aggressive renewal calls before a policy expires. These are reported experiences and are not unique to AFC — many home warranty customers face similar friction across providers. We do not accuse America's First Choice Home Club of any wrongdoing.

If you received a call or letter and you do not have an existing relationship with the company, you have no obligation to call back. You can shop a real, written home warranty quote online at any time without speaking to anyone.

Skip the phone call — get a written quote online

You don't have to negotiate over the phone or wait on hold to start home warranty coverage. Get a real written quote in minutes, see exactly what's covered, and start coverage for $99 today — no inspection required.

Get an Instant Quote & Setup Now Online

Compare other home warranty companies

Looking up a phone number? Search any home warranty phone number or browse our full list of home warranty company reviews.